Page 1 of 2
You've Been Wrong About Where the Death Star Trench Was for Your Entire Life
Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2017 12:36 pm
by kham
HereNo, I havent
Since , a) I watched the movie in 1977 and b) RTFM, or WTFB -- Watch the Fucking Briefing...
Re: You've Been Wrong About Where the Death Star Trench Was for Your Entire Life
Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2017 1:19 pm
by Mynock
Like article says it's literally in the movie lol........duh.
Re: You've Been Wrong About Where the Death Star Trench Was for Your Entire Life
Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2017 1:38 pm
by kham
Yes, plain as day
Thus proving , beyond a shadow of a doubt, the average SW fanboyz would have been blown out of the sky, while attempting to bomb the WRONG target. I'm picturing Imperial gunners doubled over and laughing their balls off while deciding who gets to shoot this one...
Re: You've Been Wrong About Where the Death Star Trench Was for Your Entire Life
Posted: Thu Jan 26, 2017 6:05 pm
by DangerGirl
Duh.
Some well-placed proton bombs or torpedoes in the hangar bays along the equatorial trench during the first wave of the attack might have made a dent in the Imperial defense of the target trench, though.
Re: You've Been Wrong About Where the Death Star Trench Was for Your Entire Life
Posted: Thu Jan 26, 2017 6:08 pm
by kham
I donno, it might have
But Vader's Elite's cut them to shreds as it was, I'm not sure provoking a launch of some of the thousands of ordinary TIEs the Death Star carried would have been good. Mind you, you can only be attacked one, or a pair at a time....
Re: You've Been Wrong About Where the Death Star Trench Was for Your Entire Life
Posted: Thu Jan 26, 2017 8:18 pm
by DangerGirl
When I was an air campaign planner, it was an axiom that you take out as much of the enemy's airpower as you can while it's still on the ground.
You could also ask why the ion cannon/blaster turrets on the Y-wings weren't used to clear their tails when they were jumped by TIEs in the trench.
Re: You've Been Wrong About Where the Death Star Trench Was for Your Entire Life
Posted: Thu Jan 26, 2017 8:53 pm
by Fred588
DangerGirl wrote:When I was an air campaign planner, it was an axiom that you take out as much of the enemy's airpower as you can while it's still on the ground.
You could also ask why the ion cannon/blaster turrets on the Y-wings weren't used to clear their tails when they were jumped by TIEs in the trench.
Because nothing was said about that in the script.
Re: You've Been Wrong About Where the Death Star Trench Was for Your Entire Life
Posted: Thu Jan 26, 2017 9:08 pm
by DangerGirl
Chekhov's gun, Fred. When you show a fighter with a gun turret, at some point in the story, that turret needs to be used.
Re: You've Been Wrong About Where the Death Star Trench Was for Your Entire Life
Posted: Sat Jan 28, 2017 9:49 pm
by nachtjaeger
The trench they attacked was a lot smaller than the equatorial trench- and it had a definite end at the exhaust port.
Much as I enjoy suspending disbelief, it would have been great to see the Y-wings' turrets in action. And drama aside, wouldn't the exhaust port have been an easier target if they had been heading vertically down at it?
Re: You've Been Wrong About Where the Death Star Trench Was for Your Entire Life
Posted: Sat Jan 28, 2017 11:13 pm
by kham
DangerGirl wrote:Chekhov's gun, Fred. When you show a fighter with a gun turret, at some point in the story, that turret needs to be used.
We did, we just had to wait 35 years to see it in the Clone Wars Series....
I mean, even a Bear has a pair of tail guns, which would make any wiseguy F-15 driver trying to polish the bullet cautious - or dead if they forgot..